LIANG Jia-jing,SONG Cai-feng,ZHU Xiang-zhi,et al.The Accuracy Rate and Error Tendencies of Apical Anterior and Posterior Sounds among Children Aged 3 - 5 Years Old[J].Chinese Scientific Journal of Hearing and Speech Rehabilitation,2025,23(02):119-122.
LIANG Jia-jing,SONG Cai-feng,ZHU Xiang-zhi,et al.The Accuracy Rate and Error Tendencies of Apical Anterior and Posterior Sounds among Children Aged 3 - 5 Years Old[J].Chinese Scientific Journal of Hearing and Speech Rehabilitation,2025,23(02):119-122.DOI: 10.3969/j.issn.1672-4933.2025.02.003.
The Accuracy Rate and Error Tendencies of Apical Anterior and Posterior Sounds among Children Aged 3 - 5 Years Old
To investigate the accuracy rate and error trends of flat and retroflex sounds among preschool children
to analyze the pronunciation difficulty of flat and retroflex sounds in different pronunciation positions
and to explore the reasons affecting their accuracy rate.
Methods
2
250 children aged 3 - 5 years old were selected. Some words from the "Articulation and Phonetic Ability Assessment Word List" were used as test materials. Descriptive statistics and non - parametric tests were used to analyze their phonetic abilities of flat and retroflex sounds.
Results
2
The number of children making mistakes in the retroflex sounds /r/
/sh/
/zh/ and the flat sound /z/ was relatively high. 17 children did not master the pronunciation of /r/ and /sh/
12 children did not master the pronunciation of /zh/
and 11 children did not master the pronunciation of /z/. The average accuracy rate of flat and retroflex sounds in the 3-year-old group was 88%
in the 4-year-old group was 93%
and in the 5-year-old group incresed to 97%. Age had a main effect
with a highly significant difference (
P
=0.002<0.0
1)
and there was a highly significant difference between the 3-year-old and 5-year-old groups (
P
=0.000<0.01). In the 3-5-year-old groups
no omission problems occurred in the error trends of flat and retroflex sounds
and they were mainly distributed in two error trends: substitution and distortion. The error trend occurrence rate in the 3-year-old group was relatively high
mostly in the form of substitution. With the increase of age
the error trend occurrence rate in the 5-year-old group gradually decreased
with occasional distortion. For preschool children aged 3 to 5 years old
when the flat sound was combined with /-i/
the main substitution process was the retroflexion of apical anterior sounds. When the flat sound was combined with /-u/
the main substitution process was also the retroflexion of apical anterior sounds. When the retroflex sound was combined with /-i/
the main substitution error process was the non - retroflexion of anterior - posterior tongue sounds. When /r/ was combined with /-ou/
the main substitution error process was the lateralization of anterior - posterior tongue sounds.
Conclusion
2
Substitution is the main form of phonological process in children's speech development. The acquisition of retroflex sounds is later than that of flat sounds. The age of 5 may be a node for the acquisition of flat and retroflex sounds.
Moisik SR , Czaykowska-Higgins E , Esling JH . Phonological potentials and the lower vocal tract [J ] . Journal of the International Phonetic Association , 2021 , 51 ( 1 ): 1 - 35 .
Babatsouli E . Correlation between the measure for cluster proximity (MCP) and the percentage of consonants correct (PCC) [J ] . Clinical Linguistics & Phonetics , 2021 , 35 ( 1 ): 65 - 83 .
Zou T , Liu Y , Zhong H . The roles of consonant, rime, and tone in mandarin spoken word recognition: an eye-tracking study [J ] . Frontiers in Psychology , 2022 , 12 : 740444 .